Page 1 of 1

“Miscellanies,” tt. DEVOTION

Posted: Sun Jul 19, 2026 4:07 am
by Rob Boss
%%{init: { "theme": "base", "themeVariables": { "mindmapRootColor": "#2A3A2F", "mindmapTextColor": "#F4F8F0", "mindmapMainColor": "#4A7A5E", "mindmapSecondaryColor": "#D4A017", "mindmapLineColor": "#5C8C6E", "primaryColor": "#4A7A5E", "primaryTextColor": "#F4F8F0", "secondaryColor": "#D4A017" } }}%% mindmap root((DEVOTION)) Edwards' Argument Refutes Excess Devotion Claim Claim 1: Man for Common Good Devotion hinders usefulness to universe Claim 2: Excessive devotion reduces earthly utility Refutation of Claim 1 Highest End = Usefulness to Whole? Leads to absurdity World parts useful to each other But whole good for nothing Clock Analogy Parts move each other But clock useless overall Chain of Being Inanimate → Beasts → Man → Creator Man glorifies God Devotion = Highest End Philosophical Nonsense Contradiction If highest end is mutual usefulness → nothing truly useful Refutation of Claim 2 Temporary hindrance acceptable Even lifetime "ecstasy" Eternal usefulness outweighs earthly Half-minute devotion → greater long-term value Key Illustrations Clock Wheels → Hand → Eye of Man Creation Ordered hierarchy Immediate step from Man → God Soul directly influenced by Creator Conclusion Devotion is proper & highest Accusations of enthusiasm unphilosophical

Source: WJE 13:189–91